Dear Senator [Metsger]:
We all know that Jefferson County needs funds to carry out its obligations to all the citizens for which it is responsible. The question is "what will be the source of those funds?"
The County Commissioners have concluded that large destination resorts in the Metolius River Basin is the answer.
A large segment of the population ,who comprise not only the residents of Camp Sherman but a multitude of out of state vacationers as well, have concluded that that is not the answer.
Their reasons have been presented to the members of the Committee on General Government and Education in great detail. Mine have been submitted in writing at the first hearing of SB30, as well as phone calls previous to the hearing.
Now I think it is time to move the debate to the basic problem--taxes for Jefferson County that can be raised in a way that won't destroy the Metolius River Basin.
Why not have a county lottery to raise money for county services? That method of raising taxes has proved to be both popular and successful in other realms of government.
I urge you to put your mind to alternatives to destination resorts in the Metolius Basin. Let us be creative rather than destructive in solving our County's tax problem.
Very truly yours,
Katherine S. Livingston
Camp Sherman, Oregon
Saturday, April 21, 2007
Other Ways of Raising Taxes? - Katherine Livingston, Camp Sherman
Dear Senator [Metsger]:
We all know that Jefferson County needs funds to carry out its obligations to all the citizens for which it is responsible. The question is "what will be the source of those funds?"
The County Commissioners have concluded that large destination resorts in the Metolius River Basin is the answer.
A large segment of the population ,who comprise not only the residents of Camp Sherman but a multitude of out of state vacationers as well, have concluded that that is not the answer.
Their reasons have been presented to the members of the Committee on General Government and Education in great detail. Mine have been submitted in writing at the first hearing of SB30, as well as phone calls previous to the hearing.
Now I think it is time to move the debate to the basic problem--taxes for Jefferson County that can be raised in a way that won't destroy the Metolius River Basin.
Why not have a county lottery to raise money for county services? That method of raising taxes has proved to be both popular and successful in other realms of government.
I urge you to put your mind to alternatives to destination resorts in the Metolius Basin. Let us be creative rather than destructive in solving our County's tax problem.
Very truly yours,
Katherine S. Livingston
Camp Sherman, Oregon
We all know that Jefferson County needs funds to carry out its obligations to all the citizens for which it is responsible. The question is "what will be the source of those funds?"
The County Commissioners have concluded that large destination resorts in the Metolius River Basin is the answer.
A large segment of the population ,who comprise not only the residents of Camp Sherman but a multitude of out of state vacationers as well, have concluded that that is not the answer.
Their reasons have been presented to the members of the Committee on General Government and Education in great detail. Mine have been submitted in writing at the first hearing of SB30, as well as phone calls previous to the hearing.
Now I think it is time to move the debate to the basic problem--taxes for Jefferson County that can be raised in a way that won't destroy the Metolius River Basin.
Why not have a county lottery to raise money for county services? That method of raising taxes has proved to be both popular and successful in other realms of government.
I urge you to put your mind to alternatives to destination resorts in the Metolius Basin. Let us be creative rather than destructive in solving our County's tax problem.
Very truly yours,
Katherine S. Livingston
Camp Sherman, Oregon
Thursday, April 19, 2007
"More Than Anyone Else" - Michael Graham, Portland
Dear Senator Johnson,
Perhaps more than anyone else in Salem you know the unique and precious character of the Metolius Basin. Thank you for your efforts with Senator Westlund to protect this outstanding asset from the rapacious development by landowners who have cowed Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
For the last 30 years we have seen the Metolius Basin community slowly grow and the growth has been relatively well managed and it's effects on the basin have been minimal.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. This pristine basin would be overwhelmed and it's unique character, a precious possession of ALL THE STATE AND, INDEED, THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, would be forever lost. All for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
We know you will keep working to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass. Thank you for your efforts!
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
Perhaps more than anyone else in Salem you know the unique and precious character of the Metolius Basin. Thank you for your efforts with Senator Westlund to protect this outstanding asset from the rapacious development by landowners who have cowed Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
For the last 30 years we have seen the Metolius Basin community slowly grow and the growth has been relatively well managed and it's effects on the basin have been minimal.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. This pristine basin would be overwhelmed and it's unique character, a precious possession of ALL THE STATE AND, INDEED, THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, would be forever lost. All for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
We know you will keep working to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass. Thank you for your efforts!
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
Get An Uncompromised Bill To The Floor - Michael Graham, Portland
Dear Senator Kruse,
This message is to implore you to stand up to the opponents of Senate Bill 30, a measure to protect the precious Metolius basin from rapacious development by landowners who have cowed the Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
For the last 30 years we have seen the Metolius Basin community slowly grow and the growth has been relatively well managed and it's effects on the basin have been minimal.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. This pristine basin would be overwhelmed and it's unique character, a precious possession of ALL THE STATE AND, INDEED, THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, would be forever lost. All for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
Please, as Vice Chair, work to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass.
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
This message is to implore you to stand up to the opponents of Senate Bill 30, a measure to protect the precious Metolius basin from rapacious development by landowners who have cowed the Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
For the last 30 years we have seen the Metolius Basin community slowly grow and the growth has been relatively well managed and it's effects on the basin have been minimal.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. This pristine basin would be overwhelmed and it's unique character, a precious possession of ALL THE STATE AND, INDEED, THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, would be forever lost. All for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
Please, as Vice Chair, work to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass.
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
Dear Senator Morse - Michael Graham, Portland
Dear Senator Morse,
This message is to implore you to stand up to the opponents of Senate Bill 30, a measure to protect the precious Metolius basin from rapacious development by landowners who have cowed the Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
For the last 30 years we have seen the Metolius Basin community slowly grow and the growth has been relatively well managed and it's effects on the basin have been minimal.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. This pristine basin would be overwhelmed and it's unique character, a precious possession of ALL THE STATE AND, INDEED, THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, would be forever lost. As a fly fisherman yourself, you have probably come to know and appreciate the beautiful Metolius River. We cannot destroy this wonderful area, all for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
Please work to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass.
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
This message is to implore you to stand up to the opponents of Senate Bill 30, a measure to protect the precious Metolius basin from rapacious development by landowners who have cowed the Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
For the last 30 years we have seen the Metolius Basin community slowly grow and the growth has been relatively well managed and it's effects on the basin have been minimal.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. This pristine basin would be overwhelmed and it's unique character, a precious possession of ALL THE STATE AND, INDEED, THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, would be forever lost. As a fly fisherman yourself, you have probably come to know and appreciate the beautiful Metolius River. We cannot destroy this wonderful area, all for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
Please work to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass.
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
Impacts Would Be Overwhelming - Michael Graham, Portland
Dear Senator Metsger,
This message is to implore you to stand up to the opponents of Senate Bill 30, a measure to protect the precious Metolius basin from rapacious development by landowners who have cowed the Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
For the last 30 years we have seen the Metolius Basin community slowly grow and the growth has been relatively well managed and it's effects on the basin have been minimal.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. This pristine basin would be overwhelmed and it's unique character, a precious possession of ALL THE STATE AND, INDEED, THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, would be forever lost. All for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
Please work to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass.
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
This message is to implore you to stand up to the opponents of Senate Bill 30, a measure to protect the precious Metolius basin from rapacious development by landowners who have cowed the Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
For the last 30 years we have seen the Metolius Basin community slowly grow and the growth has been relatively well managed and it's effects on the basin have been minimal.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. This pristine basin would be overwhelmed and it's unique character, a precious possession of ALL THE STATE AND, INDEED, THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, would be forever lost. All for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
Please work to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass.
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
A Precious Possession - Michael Graham, Portland
Dear Senator Walker,
Thank you for your efforts in standing up to the opponents of Senate Bill 30, a measure to protect the precious Metolius basin from rapacious development by landowners who have cowed the Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
For the last 30 years we have seen the Metolius Basin community slowly grow and the growth has been relatively well managed and it's effects on the basin have been minimal.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. This pristine basin would be overwhelmed and it's unique character, a precious possession of ALL THE STATE, would be forever lost. All for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
Please keep up the fight to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass.
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
Thank you for your efforts in standing up to the opponents of Senate Bill 30, a measure to protect the precious Metolius basin from rapacious development by landowners who have cowed the Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
For the last 30 years we have seen the Metolius Basin community slowly grow and the growth has been relatively well managed and it's effects on the basin have been minimal.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. This pristine basin would be overwhelmed and it's unique character, a precious possession of ALL THE STATE, would be forever lost. All for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
Please keep up the fight to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass.
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
Keep Up The Fight - Michael Graham, Portland
Dear Senator Westlund,
I want to thank you for your steadfast efforts on behalf of SB 30, a measure to protect the precious Metolius basin from rapacious development by landowners who have cowed the Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. All for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
Please keep up the fight to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass.
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
I want to thank you for your steadfast efforts on behalf of SB 30, a measure to protect the precious Metolius basin from rapacious development by landowners who have cowed the Jefferson County into submission and whose only interest is in creating obscene profits for themselves and their cronies.
The proposed development of no less than 3000 homes on on the 3500 acres of the Colson property and over 300 units on the 640 acres on the Dutch/Pacific property are simply outrageous. The destruction of wildlife habitat, the creation of colossal traffic overloading of the roads, the additional pollution created by so many new residences in the now pristine area are mind-boggling. All for a pitiful modest inflow of tax dollars to the county.
Please keep up the fight to get the others on the Senate Committee on Education and General Government to understand the harmful effects obstruction of this bill will cause and get an uncompromised bill out to the floor for a vote which I believe will pass.
The Metolius basin is a unique and precious asset to the state and the country...we cannot let it be destroyed by greedy, unthinking and uncaring so-called "developers".
Michael H. Graham, MD
Portland
Grave Concerns - Liz and David Rink, Bend
Dear Senators [Morse and Metsger],
We have lived in Central Oregon for 30 years and have grave concerns about our natural resources and wild areas. Please support SB 30 to protect the incredible Metolius River from exploitation and crowds. It is sad to go hiking on trails we have used for years only to find fences and No Trespassing signs. Central Oregon is becoming "exclusive" by excluding the very people who have loved it for years (us) and centuries (the Indians and wildlife). Come to the Metolius River in June and you won't believe the wildflowers!
Thank you for reading this.
Liz and David Rink
We have lived in Central Oregon for 30 years and have grave concerns about our natural resources and wild areas. Please support SB 30 to protect the incredible Metolius River from exploitation and crowds. It is sad to go hiking on trails we have used for years only to find fences and No Trespassing signs. Central Oregon is becoming "exclusive" by excluding the very people who have loved it for years (us) and centuries (the Indians and wildlife). Come to the Metolius River in June and you won't believe the wildflowers!
Thank you for reading this.
Liz and David Rink
Tranquility and Solitude - Ervin Siverson, Portland
Dear Senator Morse:I thank you in advance for taking the time to read my letter. I am not a developer, a lobbyist, or a representative of a wildlife organization, I am simply a man who has had the pleasure of camping and fishing in one of the most beautiful spots on this planet, and that is the Metolius River. My name is Ervin Siverson, and I live in Portland, OR. My wife and I first started going to the Metolius after she was diagnosed with breast cancer. A friend implored us to go there, to heal amongst its pines and crystal-clear waters of the Metolius. I know its tranquility and solitude helped, and my wife has been cancer free for over 10 years. We have been going there ever since, we tent camp 20 weekend a year (in all weather) and I enjoy fly-fishing in its pristine waters. If the Metolius River Basin can be developed, then nothing is sacred. Please support Senate Bill 30 in its current form; because once it is gone, it is gone. I have taken the liberty of attaching a couple of pictures of this special place. A rumor floating around is that you like to attach a fly to the end of a tapered leader as well!
Thank you,
Ervin Siverson
Portland, OR
Counting On You - Linda Davis, Sisters
Dear Senator Westlund,
I have written you previously in support of SB 30 and appreciate the
response I received from you. I just want you to know that all of us out
here in Sisters and this part of Deschutes and Jefferson counties are
counting on you to continue your unwavering support. We cannot afford
compromise! We need to ensure that the Metolius Basin remains in its
current pristine condition for future generations.
Thank you for your support!
Linda Davis
Sisters, OR
I have written you previously in support of SB 30 and appreciate the
response I received from you. I just want you to know that all of us out
here in Sisters and this part of Deschutes and Jefferson counties are
counting on you to continue your unwavering support. We cannot afford
compromise! We need to ensure that the Metolius Basin remains in its
current pristine condition for future generations.
Thank you for your support!
Linda Davis
Sisters, OR
Destroying The Goose That Laid The Golden Egg - Linda Davis, Sisters
[Sent to Senators Johnson, Kruse, Walker, Morse, and Metsger:]
I urge you in the strongest words possible to support SB 30 that would limit destination resort development in the Metolius basin. The Metolius River and its tributaries is one of the most fragile and unique water systems in the West. Upstream from Billy Chinook Lake, it remains in largely a pristine condition and significant and expensive efforts are being made to improve the ecosystem to reintroduce and expand native fish species. Destination resort development is totally incompatible with this effort. I don't care what the developers say they will or won't do, the huge numbers of people, septic tanks, water use, road development and recreators will destroy this unique river and the amenities that those who fish and recreate enjoy. It would be a classic example of destroying the goose that lays the golden egg!
I am a retired land use planner with 35 years experience, most of it in Oregon. I have rarely seen any developer who claimed that he would not impact a community not do so in the end, sometimes with the best of intentions and measures not to do so. There are too many unknowns in an area like this that can cause destruction. The soils, groundwater aquifer system -- so unique -- the vegetation, the bull trout population in the river are all potential impacted by this proposed development. We can add to the list of concerns forest fire danger which would increase immensely being so close to the Deschutes National Forest and Jefferson Wilderness area.
The shear number of people that would be in the area, long after the developers have left, will have impacts beyond what we can imagine. For example, Highway 20 and Sisters cannot possibly handle the level of traffic congestion that such a resort would cause. Highway 20 is already one of the most dangerous stretches of highway in Oregon, largely caused by the numbers of people that come over the pass on weekends and other peak holiday periods. I realize that this issue spans just the proposed resorts in the Metolius Basin, but we need to start somewhere to address this enormous problem.
Thank you for supporting SB 30.
Linda L. Davis
Sisters, OR
I urge you in the strongest words possible to support SB 30 that would limit destination resort development in the Metolius basin. The Metolius River and its tributaries is one of the most fragile and unique water systems in the West. Upstream from Billy Chinook Lake, it remains in largely a pristine condition and significant and expensive efforts are being made to improve the ecosystem to reintroduce and expand native fish species. Destination resort development is totally incompatible with this effort. I don't care what the developers say they will or won't do, the huge numbers of people, septic tanks, water use, road development and recreators will destroy this unique river and the amenities that those who fish and recreate enjoy. It would be a classic example of destroying the goose that lays the golden egg!
I am a retired land use planner with 35 years experience, most of it in Oregon. I have rarely seen any developer who claimed that he would not impact a community not do so in the end, sometimes with the best of intentions and measures not to do so. There are too many unknowns in an area like this that can cause destruction. The soils, groundwater aquifer system -- so unique -- the vegetation, the bull trout population in the river are all potential impacted by this proposed development. We can add to the list of concerns forest fire danger which would increase immensely being so close to the Deschutes National Forest and Jefferson Wilderness area.
The shear number of people that would be in the area, long after the developers have left, will have impacts beyond what we can imagine. For example, Highway 20 and Sisters cannot possibly handle the level of traffic congestion that such a resort would cause. Highway 20 is already one of the most dangerous stretches of highway in Oregon, largely caused by the numbers of people that come over the pass on weekends and other peak holiday periods. I realize that this issue spans just the proposed resorts in the Metolius Basin, but we need to start somewhere to address this enormous problem.
Thank you for supporting SB 30.
Linda L. Davis
Sisters, OR
Wednesday, April 18, 2007
The Metolius: A Much Needed Break After Harvest - Pat Malone, Philomath OR
Chair Walker and Members of the committee:
[Hand Delivered]
My name is Pat Malone and I live at 24048 Maxfield Creek Road. Philomath, Oregon 97370. I am here today in support of Senate Bill 30. My Father and Grandfather were wheat ranchers in the Antelope area of Wasco County. They started coming to vacation on the Metolius River over one hundred years ago. It was a much needed break after the hay season and before the wheat harvest. My brother and I grew up on stories of the river and the annual trek there.
A good part of my motivation for getting up early today and putting aside the work I planned to do is to represent those that came before me and are no longer alive. The Metolius was special to them and the current generation has a responsibility to take care of this unique and special area.
I started going to Camp Sherman when I was a little kid in the early 1950’s. I remember lots of hiking along the Metolius, the lush grass, the ponderosa pine, the spectacular colors of Wizard Falls and the coldest water I have ever been in.
My wife and I took our kids to the Metolius many times as they were growing up and hope that this tradition will continue when they have children. The Metolius is a very special place for my family that needs our stewardship so that Oregonians today and in the future can enjoy its wonders.
Please pass SB 30 as quickly as possible.
Thank you.
Pat Malone
Philomath, Oregon
[Hand Delivered]
My name is Pat Malone and I live at 24048 Maxfield Creek Road. Philomath, Oregon 97370. I am here today in support of Senate Bill 30. My Father and Grandfather were wheat ranchers in the Antelope area of Wasco County. They started coming to vacation on the Metolius River over one hundred years ago. It was a much needed break after the hay season and before the wheat harvest. My brother and I grew up on stories of the river and the annual trek there.
A good part of my motivation for getting up early today and putting aside the work I planned to do is to represent those that came before me and are no longer alive. The Metolius was special to them and the current generation has a responsibility to take care of this unique and special area.
I started going to Camp Sherman when I was a little kid in the early 1950’s. I remember lots of hiking along the Metolius, the lush grass, the ponderosa pine, the spectacular colors of Wizard Falls and the coldest water I have ever been in.
My wife and I took our kids to the Metolius many times as they were growing up and hope that this tradition will continue when they have children. The Metolius is a very special place for my family that needs our stewardship so that Oregonians today and in the future can enjoy its wonders.
Please pass SB 30 as quickly as possible.
Thank you.
Pat Malone
Philomath, Oregon
No Going Back - Ervin Siverson, Portland
Dear Senator Metsger:My name is Ervin Siverson and I live in Portland, OR. I am not a developer, a lobbyist, or represent any wildlife organization. I only write to speak of my love for the Metolius River Basin, a special place that has no voice. I first fell in love with the Metolius after my wife was diagnosed with breast cancer. One of our friends implored us to go there and seek solitude amongst the pines and the pristine Metolius River. I know it helped with my wife's (and mine) healing, and she has been cancer free for over ten years. Since then, we have camped there at least 20 weekends a year, fishing its special waters and hiking its many trails. This place is special, it should never be developed, it is fragile, and once it is developed and possibly ruined, there is no going back. This is why I support Senate Bill 30 in its current form. I have taken the liberty to include two photos of this special place, thanks in advance for your attention and consideration.
Ervin Siverson
Portland, OR
Tuesday, April 17, 2007
Matters Generally Overlooked - Katherine Livingston, Camp Sherman
The Hon, Vicki Walker, Senator
State House
Salem, Oregon
RE: SB 30
Dear Senator Walker,
May I first of all express my appreciation of the fine way in which you conducted the hearing on April 5th concerning SB30, even though enough time was not reserved for hearing the supporters of that bill.
Before the hearing I submitted my written testimony. Had I had the opportunity to speak I would have added the following points which I believe are worthy of serious consideration.
In testimony and discussion two matters are generally overlooked:
1) The Metolius River Basin as a State as well as Federal responsibility in that it is not just local, but situated within The Deschtes National Forest.
2) Alternatives to destination resorts within or near the Basin as a source of tax revenues for Jefferson County.
There has been ample and moving testimony to preserve the integrity of the Metoliius River and environs from those who have known and loved it for generations, to say nothing of the testimony of more recent residents of the area who are equally concerned about the river and its future.
There is no denying that the Metolius River is unique among the rivers of our nation. It is not awesome in size and grandeur as are the Columbia, The Missouri, the Mississippi, the Madison, to say nothing of the Amazon and the Congo. The Metolius is a small river, a unique and multi-faceted gem set in a unique and multifaceted masterpiece of Nature. It is fragile and vulnerable, and it's life source is not renewable. To threaten both the source and the purity of its waters by destination resorts is unthinkable and irresponsible.
As to the adequate funding of Jefferson County's obligations to the residents of the state through a new tax source there is no question, but it is how and where. That, I believe, should be the debate.
The Metolius River Basin is a treasure for the entire state, and the entire state should share the burden of preserving it. Can we not put our minds together for working out creative ways to generate income for the County? Perhaps even for the whole state. A special tax dedicated to preserving all of its wonders, from coast to forest to desert.
In all of my 92 years of life I have seen much of the world-- rivers, mountains deserts and forests, and nothing can compare to what we are blessed to have in the state of Oregon. Sometimes we don't appreciate what is at our very door. Let's not go down that slippery slope and find nothing at the end.
I look forward to a second hearing. Thank you again for your fair minded approach to this very sensitive issue.
Sincerely,
Katherine S. Livingston
(Camp Sherman, OR)
State House
Salem, Oregon
RE: SB 30
Dear Senator Walker,
May I first of all express my appreciation of the fine way in which you conducted the hearing on April 5th concerning SB30, even though enough time was not reserved for hearing the supporters of that bill.
Before the hearing I submitted my written testimony. Had I had the opportunity to speak I would have added the following points which I believe are worthy of serious consideration.
In testimony and discussion two matters are generally overlooked:
1) The Metolius River Basin as a State as well as Federal responsibility in that it is not just local, but situated within The Deschtes National Forest.
2) Alternatives to destination resorts within or near the Basin as a source of tax revenues for Jefferson County.
There has been ample and moving testimony to preserve the integrity of the Metoliius River and environs from those who have known and loved it for generations, to say nothing of the testimony of more recent residents of the area who are equally concerned about the river and its future.
There is no denying that the Metolius River is unique among the rivers of our nation. It is not awesome in size and grandeur as are the Columbia, The Missouri, the Mississippi, the Madison, to say nothing of the Amazon and the Congo. The Metolius is a small river, a unique and multi-faceted gem set in a unique and multifaceted masterpiece of Nature. It is fragile and vulnerable, and it's life source is not renewable. To threaten both the source and the purity of its waters by destination resorts is unthinkable and irresponsible.
As to the adequate funding of Jefferson County's obligations to the residents of the state through a new tax source there is no question, but it is how and where. That, I believe, should be the debate.
The Metolius River Basin is a treasure for the entire state, and the entire state should share the burden of preserving it. Can we not put our minds together for working out creative ways to generate income for the County? Perhaps even for the whole state. A special tax dedicated to preserving all of its wonders, from coast to forest to desert.
In all of my 92 years of life I have seen much of the world-- rivers, mountains deserts and forests, and nothing can compare to what we are blessed to have in the state of Oregon. Sometimes we don't appreciate what is at our very door. Let's not go down that slippery slope and find nothing at the end.
I look forward to a second hearing. Thank you again for your fair minded approach to this very sensitive issue.
Sincerely,
Katherine S. Livingston
(Camp Sherman, OR)
Monday, April 16, 2007
What the Metolius River Means To Me - Kathy Krause, Portland
(To Senators Westlund, Johnson, Walker, Kruse, Morse, and Metsger)
I first visited the Metolius River when I was eight years old. This river was where my family spent summer vacation time. We would stay in a very old cabin (Lake Creek Lodge) and spend summer days and nights along the river.
As a child:
The summer days consisted of hikes along the river, riding my bike two miles to the headwaters and feeding the squirrels as I walked down the short path to see the beautiful river emerge out of the side of a hill into a large green, grassy meadow with a beautiful snowcapped mountain behind it. I would always ask the same question, "How does a river just come out of the hill"? I would build stick boats out of grass and bark which I would float from one bridge to another while racing down the bank of the river trying to "beat my boat" to the next bridge. I would find Salmon Flies in the bushes along the bank and toss them into the river and watch the large trout jump. I remember a fisherman explaining what "chumming" meant. Actually, I think he was grateful to see there were fish in the river, as he hadn't had any luck that day. I took up fishing myself. Lake Creek Lodge had a pond that was created by Lake Creek and kids were allowed to fish if your fishing pole was made from a long stick. I caught my very first fish in that pond. Dusk was the time for evening walks in hopes of spotting deer. Deer and stars were the glory of dusk. Why weren't the stars in Portland this big? Shooting stars meant a wish might come true. Many wishes were made on Metolius evenings. Nights were spent reading, playing cards and games. There were no televisions or phones and no need for them. This was time for family and friends and usually we were so tired, or so excited for the next days events that bedtime came early and easily. Who needed outdoor school when summer break was spent learning about ecosystems on a river through every day playing!
As a teenager:
Time at the Metolius was spent riding my bike and floating down the river on an innertube. The water was freezing, but the excitement of almost not fitting under the Allingham bridge made up for it. The Camp Sherman store was the perfect place to spend my hard earned babysitting money on candy and popcorn. Walking along the river as a teenager I learned what it meant to feel peaceful. I remember always feeling the Metolius was a happy place, full of wonderful memories and I always felt good when I was there. My parents were no longer married, and the family times were a bit different, but just being on the banks of the river made me feel safe and happy. It was as a teenager that I decided the large grassy wildflower meadow just before the Allingham Bridge was my meadow. It was the best place for stargazing, running and identifying wildflowers. The stars there were huge!
As a college student:
I introduced my college friends to camping at the Metolius. I was amazed that no one knew about Camp Sherman and this river! Friends who had grown up in Portland knew about Sun River, the beach, Black Butte, but never the Metolius. I felt so proud showing them how "my" river came out of the side of a hill! Everyone loved the area! "Norman Rockwell" was what came to mind. I still remember showing one of my friends the post office library and the expression on her face when I explained the "honor" system of taking books home to read. "You just help yourself to a book or magazine and then bring it back or bring another one for someone else to read". I remember as a child getting the Highlights magazine from the Camp Sherman Post Office library. Just like at the issues at the doctors office, all of the hidden puzzles had been completed by someone else.
Camping on the Metolius was fantastic! We would camp in the "hike in" area (our car was only a few hundred feet away) and we felt like we were in the middle of nowhere! For the first time, I felt like a grown up! It was so beautiful! The Metolius was untouched by human hands, and was magically and completely uninterrupted! I was very protective over the campsite. I was meticulous about making sure the campfire was completely out, I would triple check to make sure we hadn't left any indication of ever being there. I took pride in "my river" and wanted it to be as it always was - untouched by human hands. I knew what a special place it was and that I should leave it in better condition than when I arrived. We spent many wonderful college breaks camping on the Metolius! What happened on the Metolius will stay on the Metolius.
As an adult:
I realize what my experience on this river has given me and how it has affected who I am as an adult. I reflect on how blessed I am to have spent my childhood on a wild and scenic river. I have an inner peace, which is to this day, is ignited by the spiritual and pristine banks of the Metolius River. I am able to show young children how to spend summer days without television or video games and learn they crave the same experience of learning about nature and using nature as a playground that I did. I appreciate and love to be able to escape to an area where there isn't crime, billboards, television, traffic, noise and stress. I am able to know what a peaceful place is and as an adult, work as hard as I can to get time away from the grind of adulthood to go back to the river for a piece of it. I am able to realize how sacred and special places like the Metolius River are and that as an adult it is my duty to protect and save these treasures for future generations. I know now what an incredible and generous gift the land around the headwaters donated by the Johnson family is! Private land not only donated for the public to use and enjoy, but also specifically designed so that people with disabilities would be able to get down the path to see the beautiful river emerge from the side of a hill! This alone speaks of the passion one feels when one is touched by this beautiful place - you just want to share it with everyone in its current and untouched, pristine and magical state! No one can explain to me how beautiful, natural landscapes have come to be. However, I do know how they make us feel when we experience them. There is a price to pay for this type of beauty and that price is managed and restricted use and full protection. The Metolius River Recreation Area has and always will be available to visit, but it is home to our fish and wildlife and we (humans) are visitors. To allow "humans" to call this area home will destroy exactly what has drawn us to this special area to begin with. As an adult, I have a voice. I work hard, live my life responsibly and accountably and have earned my voice. Much like a child, nature has no voice. It is up to adults to speak up and be the voice for nature and children. I hope I may thank the banks of the Metolius for making me the adult I am by speaking for the river in demanding its protection.
-Kathy Krause, Portland, OR
I first visited the Metolius River when I was eight years old. This river was where my family spent summer vacation time. We would stay in a very old cabin (Lake Creek Lodge) and spend summer days and nights along the river.
As a child:
The summer days consisted of hikes along the river, riding my bike two miles to the headwaters and feeding the squirrels as I walked down the short path to see the beautiful river emerge out of the side of a hill into a large green, grassy meadow with a beautiful snowcapped mountain behind it. I would always ask the same question, "How does a river just come out of the hill"? I would build stick boats out of grass and bark which I would float from one bridge to another while racing down the bank of the river trying to "beat my boat" to the next bridge. I would find Salmon Flies in the bushes along the bank and toss them into the river and watch the large trout jump. I remember a fisherman explaining what "chumming" meant. Actually, I think he was grateful to see there were fish in the river, as he hadn't had any luck that day. I took up fishing myself. Lake Creek Lodge had a pond that was created by Lake Creek and kids were allowed to fish if your fishing pole was made from a long stick. I caught my very first fish in that pond. Dusk was the time for evening walks in hopes of spotting deer. Deer and stars were the glory of dusk. Why weren't the stars in Portland this big? Shooting stars meant a wish might come true. Many wishes were made on Metolius evenings. Nights were spent reading, playing cards and games. There were no televisions or phones and no need for them. This was time for family and friends and usually we were so tired, or so excited for the next days events that bedtime came early and easily. Who needed outdoor school when summer break was spent learning about ecosystems on a river through every day playing!
As a teenager:
Time at the Metolius was spent riding my bike and floating down the river on an innertube. The water was freezing, but the excitement of almost not fitting under the Allingham bridge made up for it. The Camp Sherman store was the perfect place to spend my hard earned babysitting money on candy and popcorn. Walking along the river as a teenager I learned what it meant to feel peaceful. I remember always feeling the Metolius was a happy place, full of wonderful memories and I always felt good when I was there. My parents were no longer married, and the family times were a bit different, but just being on the banks of the river made me feel safe and happy. It was as a teenager that I decided the large grassy wildflower meadow just before the Allingham Bridge was my meadow. It was the best place for stargazing, running and identifying wildflowers. The stars there were huge!
As a college student:
I introduced my college friends to camping at the Metolius. I was amazed that no one knew about Camp Sherman and this river! Friends who had grown up in Portland knew about Sun River, the beach, Black Butte, but never the Metolius. I felt so proud showing them how "my" river came out of the side of a hill! Everyone loved the area! "Norman Rockwell" was what came to mind. I still remember showing one of my friends the post office library and the expression on her face when I explained the "honor" system of taking books home to read. "You just help yourself to a book or magazine and then bring it back or bring another one for someone else to read". I remember as a child getting the Highlights magazine from the Camp Sherman Post Office library. Just like at the issues at the doctors office, all of the hidden puzzles had been completed by someone else.
Camping on the Metolius was fantastic! We would camp in the "hike in" area (our car was only a few hundred feet away) and we felt like we were in the middle of nowhere! For the first time, I felt like a grown up! It was so beautiful! The Metolius was untouched by human hands, and was magically and completely uninterrupted! I was very protective over the campsite. I was meticulous about making sure the campfire was completely out, I would triple check to make sure we hadn't left any indication of ever being there. I took pride in "my river" and wanted it to be as it always was - untouched by human hands. I knew what a special place it was and that I should leave it in better condition than when I arrived. We spent many wonderful college breaks camping on the Metolius! What happened on the Metolius will stay on the Metolius.
As an adult:
I realize what my experience on this river has given me and how it has affected who I am as an adult. I reflect on how blessed I am to have spent my childhood on a wild and scenic river. I have an inner peace, which is to this day, is ignited by the spiritual and pristine banks of the Metolius River. I am able to show young children how to spend summer days without television or video games and learn they crave the same experience of learning about nature and using nature as a playground that I did. I appreciate and love to be able to escape to an area where there isn't crime, billboards, television, traffic, noise and stress. I am able to know what a peaceful place is and as an adult, work as hard as I can to get time away from the grind of adulthood to go back to the river for a piece of it. I am able to realize how sacred and special places like the Metolius River are and that as an adult it is my duty to protect and save these treasures for future generations. I know now what an incredible and generous gift the land around the headwaters donated by the Johnson family is! Private land not only donated for the public to use and enjoy, but also specifically designed so that people with disabilities would be able to get down the path to see the beautiful river emerge from the side of a hill! This alone speaks of the passion one feels when one is touched by this beautiful place - you just want to share it with everyone in its current and untouched, pristine and magical state! No one can explain to me how beautiful, natural landscapes have come to be. However, I do know how they make us feel when we experience them. There is a price to pay for this type of beauty and that price is managed and restricted use and full protection. The Metolius River Recreation Area has and always will be available to visit, but it is home to our fish and wildlife and we (humans) are visitors. To allow "humans" to call this area home will destroy exactly what has drawn us to this special area to begin with. As an adult, I have a voice. I work hard, live my life responsibly and accountably and have earned my voice. Much like a child, nature has no voice. It is up to adults to speak up and be the voice for nature and children. I hope I may thank the banks of the Metolius for making me the adult I am by speaking for the river in demanding its protection.
-Kathy Krause, Portland, OR
Metolius: Not A Landing Pad For Resorts - Kathy Krause, Portland
(To Senators Westlund, Johnson, Walker, Kruse, Morse, and Metsger)
Subject: SB 30 - Metolius
I am writing again to express and URGE support of SB 30 - Metolius. I support growth, enjoy golf and resorts. HOWEVER, great thought needs to made in where these types of resorts land. The Metolius River Basin is not an appropriate landing pad for large resorts! The current Senate Bill 30 is only requesting a "three mile buffer" from the River Basin. Not much to ask. I appreciate the process that goes into Land Use decisions, but the Metolius River and surrounding area is a gift to all Oregonians, not just Jefferson County residents and elected officials. There are plenty of appropriate places for resorts. Development next to one of our States most unique examples of a wild and scenic river is not one of them!
The Metolius River exemplifies Oregon treasures - beautiful, natural, untouched environments that provide a safe refuge and haven to visitors (humans) and occupants (nature and wildlife). It is imperative we step in and protect this area as legislature in the past has done for places like our beaches and the Columbia River Gorge! If we do not act now to protect this unique and pristine treasure, we will some day ask why no one cared!
As a resident of Oregon for 33 of my 38 years, I depend on the Legislature of Oregon to be my voice. I rely on careful decisions to be made protecting our State, our environment and what has kept me in Oregon most of my life - a scenic, pristine, livable place that is home to fish and wildlife, beautiful and untouched landscapes and a place for nature to be what it is - a natural environment. Please be my voice and support restriction on growth in this treasured and unique piece of Oregon. If you aren't familiar with Camp Sherman and the Metolius River, please take a 2.5 hour drive from Portland and see for yourself what the magical area offers. After one visit, you will understand, as I do, why more than ever, this little piece of Oregon needs to be watched, cared for and protected!
My work has allowed me to travel all over the world, and I have never seen or experienced anything else that compares to this unique river and surrounding area! I have brought visitors from around the world for day trips and hikes to share in the beauty of this river. The comments are always the same - "What a magical and spiritual area!" Everyone I have ever shared this area with is in awe over the pristine and serene environment and struck by the peaceful and uninterrupted magic of nature. Again, we (humans) are just visitors and it is home to nature and wildlife, and it needs to be kept that way!
The proposed resorts are interested in this area for the above reasons, and will only destroy what drew them there to begin with! Again, I support growth, enjoy resorts and golf. However, I do not support sacrificing an area which needs to be protected and can currently be enjoyed by everyone to the hands of a few who have the funds to change its existing scenic and wild habitat forever. This river belongs to all Oregonians. It is home to the fish and wildlife and is one of the finest examples of a wild and scenic area in the world. Oregonians are proud to have scenic areas like the Metolius in our State! It is the very reason most of us have chosen to live here. This area can never be recreated or "fixed" if it is harmed. The Metolius River Basin is not able to support humans as residents, nor should it be! The Metolius River Basin is not just another piece of dirt with a river running through it! It is a National treasure and one that Oregon is darned lucky to have! This area has been protected by the Federal Government and private parties for years, and there is a reason for that.
Thank you for you time and consideration!
Kathy Krause
Portland, Oregon
Subject: SB 30 - Metolius
I am writing again to express and URGE support of SB 30 - Metolius. I support growth, enjoy golf and resorts. HOWEVER, great thought needs to made in where these types of resorts land. The Metolius River Basin is not an appropriate landing pad for large resorts! The current Senate Bill 30 is only requesting a "three mile buffer" from the River Basin. Not much to ask. I appreciate the process that goes into Land Use decisions, but the Metolius River and surrounding area is a gift to all Oregonians, not just Jefferson County residents and elected officials. There are plenty of appropriate places for resorts. Development next to one of our States most unique examples of a wild and scenic river is not one of them!
The Metolius River exemplifies Oregon treasures - beautiful, natural, untouched environments that provide a safe refuge and haven to visitors (humans) and occupants (nature and wildlife). It is imperative we step in and protect this area as legislature in the past has done for places like our beaches and the Columbia River Gorge! If we do not act now to protect this unique and pristine treasure, we will some day ask why no one cared!
As a resident of Oregon for 33 of my 38 years, I depend on the Legislature of Oregon to be my voice. I rely on careful decisions to be made protecting our State, our environment and what has kept me in Oregon most of my life - a scenic, pristine, livable place that is home to fish and wildlife, beautiful and untouched landscapes and a place for nature to be what it is - a natural environment. Please be my voice and support restriction on growth in this treasured and unique piece of Oregon. If you aren't familiar with Camp Sherman and the Metolius River, please take a 2.5 hour drive from Portland and see for yourself what the magical area offers. After one visit, you will understand, as I do, why more than ever, this little piece of Oregon needs to be watched, cared for and protected!
My work has allowed me to travel all over the world, and I have never seen or experienced anything else that compares to this unique river and surrounding area! I have brought visitors from around the world for day trips and hikes to share in the beauty of this river. The comments are always the same - "What a magical and spiritual area!" Everyone I have ever shared this area with is in awe over the pristine and serene environment and struck by the peaceful and uninterrupted magic of nature. Again, we (humans) are just visitors and it is home to nature and wildlife, and it needs to be kept that way!
The proposed resorts are interested in this area for the above reasons, and will only destroy what drew them there to begin with! Again, I support growth, enjoy resorts and golf. However, I do not support sacrificing an area which needs to be protected and can currently be enjoyed by everyone to the hands of a few who have the funds to change its existing scenic and wild habitat forever. This river belongs to all Oregonians. It is home to the fish and wildlife and is one of the finest examples of a wild and scenic area in the world. Oregonians are proud to have scenic areas like the Metolius in our State! It is the very reason most of us have chosen to live here. This area can never be recreated or "fixed" if it is harmed. The Metolius River Basin is not able to support humans as residents, nor should it be! The Metolius River Basin is not just another piece of dirt with a river running through it! It is a National treasure and one that Oregon is darned lucky to have! This area has been protected by the Federal Government and private parties for years, and there is a reason for that.
Thank you for you time and consideration!
Kathy Krause
Portland, Oregon
Sunday, April 15, 2007
A Letter of My Own - Erik Kancler, Bend
Dear Senator Walker,
As the executive director of Central Oregon LandWatch, I have spent a fair amount of time talking to people about the importance of SB 30 and urging them to write letters to you, to the other members of the Senate General Government and Education Committee, and to their own friends, in support of this important piece of legislation. It occurred to me, however, that I have yet to submit a letter of my own.
The following letter does not reflect my professional views, nor those of Central Oregon LandWatch, but rather my own personal views as a concerned citizen of Central Oregon, and my belief that SB 30 is a just, fair, and badly needed piece of legislation that can offer protection for one of the state’s greatest and most imperiled natural treasures.
First off, in response to comments made by Shane Lundgren at the first hearing: as far as this country goes, I’m not a fourth generation anything. On both sides, my family immigrated here from Central and Eastern Europe in the early 1900s in search of a better life. I have trouble believing that my perspectives and viewpoints and concerns are therefore less valid than someone who’s family has been here since the 1700s. Yet, Mr. Lundgren has appealed to your committee to dismiss the arguments of those with less “tenure” than himself.
My wife and I are trying to start a family and make a life for ourselves in Central Oregon, and someday we hope that our children will grace us with grandchildren. Shouldn’t we be talking about them and what the Metolius may mean for their generations, not our grandparents? I’m not trying to sound canned here, but I really do think this is what the debate is all about.
As for the hundreds of residents who have lived near the Metolius for less than twenty years and have shown tremendous commitment to protect the river and its surrounding environment, it’s disappointing that someone would suggest their testimony should be disregarded. Or the countless people who have regularly visited the Metolius to fish or to spend time with their families. Or the countless more people who have been casual visitors to the Metolius but who upon visiting have taken home an impression of the place and an appreciation for places like it and for the natural environment in general. Then there are those who have never been to the Metolius but who take solace in the fact that it’s there, whether it’s an hour out their door or ten. Maybe they’ll go some day, may not. Either way, its natural presence has value.
Personally, I fall into the category of casual visitor. I’ve been there a mere handful of times. But I’ve walked miles of its shores, marveled at the headwaters, sat on a log with my wife snacking on crackers and cheese, content to sit silently, fully aware that the energy we were gathering from those few moments, far from the hustle and bustle of our lives, would satisfy us for weeks to come.
Not only am I not a fourth-generation Metolian, I haven’t (yet) hiked the entire Pacific Trail. I admire Mr. Keane for completing such an impressive journey, but I have to ask whether or not it’s relevant to the matter at hand. After all, it’s the ethics that a person lives his or her life by, both personally and professionally, not the places he or she has been that make them a friend of the environment.
I have lived in the West my entire life, in our near places of great beauty. I’ve backpacked, hiked, set up camp, climbed peaks, soaked, fished, surfed, canoed, kayaked, and lay in the sun on countless rocks of every color throughout the American West. The list of places I’ve been, experiences I’ve had, and wonders I’ve seen is long. I could go through them in detail, but to what end?
After all, none of that makes me a good friend to the environment. What it means is that I’ve busted my knees, run out of water, fended off hypothermia and heat stroke, endured mosquito bites, fallen into poison oak, taped up blisters, nearly fallen off cliffs, or been swept away by roaring rivers in order to enjoy some of the most amazing places in the West. What it means is that I can recognize the value and rarity of a place like the Metolius when I see it. And I’m acutely aware of the places whose beauty have been diminished – not enhanced – by inappropriate development or lack of proper management.
I can say unequivocally, that if the Metolius if allowed to succumb to destination resorts, much of its unique beauty will be lost.
I realize (or am told) that things seem to be heading in the direction of compromise. I had hoped that in this case a line in the sand would be drawn, and in fact I still hope that one is drawn, because you can’t put a price an what it means to have large primitive areas of such natural beauty devoid of and far from intense development. I worry that this perspective is easily lost when invariably pitted against the more tangible considerations that must be made when coming to decisions regarding development and the environment.
Only very rarely does environmental protection seem to be sought by developers above financial returns. Sometimes the two can coincide to an extent, and I admire developers who seek this ground, but in most cases environmental protection must be demanded by the market or – in one way or another – by the government. The Metolius is not going to protect itself, and Jefferson County is clearly unwilling to do so. The resort market places little premium if any on environmental protection. The matter has fallen to the state legislature, and so it seems, you’re its last line of defense.
I’d urge that – if a compromise is the only political option available – where the developers make promises of being sensitive, being green, being “eco-friendly,” you find ways to hold them to their word. Otherwise one thing after another will fail to pencil out, and the resulting development may provide no special protections at all. I hate to believe that this is the case, and it may not be anyone’s intention at the outset, but it seems to happen with remarkable regularity.
For what it’s worth, and despite the imbalance of time given to the pro-resort interests thus far in hearings and (I’m told) in last week’s work group, I have appreciated the comments you have made, the questions you have asked, and the context you have brought to the debate. I don’t know how you are planning on voting on SB 30, only that your perspective seems to me to be a healthy one.
Please, don’t allow the Metolius to be unnecessarily compromised by resort development. The legislature has already protected the Columbia River Gorge. Jefferson County has plenty of room elsewhere for resorts. None of what they are proposing is necessary. Even in areas of little natural significance resorts and their impacts have proven problematic – a problem to be addressed at a later time.
That’s all I have to say. Thanks for listening, for keeping an open mind, and for the many hours you’ve no doubt already devoted to this matter.
Regards,
Erik Kancler
Bend, OR
As the executive director of Central Oregon LandWatch, I have spent a fair amount of time talking to people about the importance of SB 30 and urging them to write letters to you, to the other members of the Senate General Government and Education Committee, and to their own friends, in support of this important piece of legislation. It occurred to me, however, that I have yet to submit a letter of my own.
The following letter does not reflect my professional views, nor those of Central Oregon LandWatch, but rather my own personal views as a concerned citizen of Central Oregon, and my belief that SB 30 is a just, fair, and badly needed piece of legislation that can offer protection for one of the state’s greatest and most imperiled natural treasures.
First off, in response to comments made by Shane Lundgren at the first hearing: as far as this country goes, I’m not a fourth generation anything. On both sides, my family immigrated here from Central and Eastern Europe in the early 1900s in search of a better life. I have trouble believing that my perspectives and viewpoints and concerns are therefore less valid than someone who’s family has been here since the 1700s. Yet, Mr. Lundgren has appealed to your committee to dismiss the arguments of those with less “tenure” than himself.
My wife and I are trying to start a family and make a life for ourselves in Central Oregon, and someday we hope that our children will grace us with grandchildren. Shouldn’t we be talking about them and what the Metolius may mean for their generations, not our grandparents? I’m not trying to sound canned here, but I really do think this is what the debate is all about.
As for the hundreds of residents who have lived near the Metolius for less than twenty years and have shown tremendous commitment to protect the river and its surrounding environment, it’s disappointing that someone would suggest their testimony should be disregarded. Or the countless people who have regularly visited the Metolius to fish or to spend time with their families. Or the countless more people who have been casual visitors to the Metolius but who upon visiting have taken home an impression of the place and an appreciation for places like it and for the natural environment in general. Then there are those who have never been to the Metolius but who take solace in the fact that it’s there, whether it’s an hour out their door or ten. Maybe they’ll go some day, may not. Either way, its natural presence has value.
Personally, I fall into the category of casual visitor. I’ve been there a mere handful of times. But I’ve walked miles of its shores, marveled at the headwaters, sat on a log with my wife snacking on crackers and cheese, content to sit silently, fully aware that the energy we were gathering from those few moments, far from the hustle and bustle of our lives, would satisfy us for weeks to come.
Not only am I not a fourth-generation Metolian, I haven’t (yet) hiked the entire Pacific Trail. I admire Mr. Keane for completing such an impressive journey, but I have to ask whether or not it’s relevant to the matter at hand. After all, it’s the ethics that a person lives his or her life by, both personally and professionally, not the places he or she has been that make them a friend of the environment.
I have lived in the West my entire life, in our near places of great beauty. I’ve backpacked, hiked, set up camp, climbed peaks, soaked, fished, surfed, canoed, kayaked, and lay in the sun on countless rocks of every color throughout the American West. The list of places I’ve been, experiences I’ve had, and wonders I’ve seen is long. I could go through them in detail, but to what end?
After all, none of that makes me a good friend to the environment. What it means is that I’ve busted my knees, run out of water, fended off hypothermia and heat stroke, endured mosquito bites, fallen into poison oak, taped up blisters, nearly fallen off cliffs, or been swept away by roaring rivers in order to enjoy some of the most amazing places in the West. What it means is that I can recognize the value and rarity of a place like the Metolius when I see it. And I’m acutely aware of the places whose beauty have been diminished – not enhanced – by inappropriate development or lack of proper management.
I can say unequivocally, that if the Metolius if allowed to succumb to destination resorts, much of its unique beauty will be lost.
I realize (or am told) that things seem to be heading in the direction of compromise. I had hoped that in this case a line in the sand would be drawn, and in fact I still hope that one is drawn, because you can’t put a price an what it means to have large primitive areas of such natural beauty devoid of and far from intense development. I worry that this perspective is easily lost when invariably pitted against the more tangible considerations that must be made when coming to decisions regarding development and the environment.
Only very rarely does environmental protection seem to be sought by developers above financial returns. Sometimes the two can coincide to an extent, and I admire developers who seek this ground, but in most cases environmental protection must be demanded by the market or – in one way or another – by the government. The Metolius is not going to protect itself, and Jefferson County is clearly unwilling to do so. The resort market places little premium if any on environmental protection. The matter has fallen to the state legislature, and so it seems, you’re its last line of defense.
I’d urge that – if a compromise is the only political option available – where the developers make promises of being sensitive, being green, being “eco-friendly,” you find ways to hold them to their word. Otherwise one thing after another will fail to pencil out, and the resulting development may provide no special protections at all. I hate to believe that this is the case, and it may not be anyone’s intention at the outset, but it seems to happen with remarkable regularity.
For what it’s worth, and despite the imbalance of time given to the pro-resort interests thus far in hearings and (I’m told) in last week’s work group, I have appreciated the comments you have made, the questions you have asked, and the context you have brought to the debate. I don’t know how you are planning on voting on SB 30, only that your perspective seems to me to be a healthy one.
Please, don’t allow the Metolius to be unnecessarily compromised by resort development. The legislature has already protected the Columbia River Gorge. Jefferson County has plenty of room elsewhere for resorts. None of what they are proposing is necessary. Even in areas of little natural significance resorts and their impacts have proven problematic – a problem to be addressed at a later time.
That’s all I have to say. Thanks for listening, for keeping an open mind, and for the many hours you’ve no doubt already devoted to this matter.
Regards,
Erik Kancler
Bend, OR
Need To Be Forward Thinking - Eva Dougherty, Seattle
Dear Senator Walker,
I am writing this e-mail to express my support for SB 30 as written. I currently reside in Seattle, WA. However, I grew up in Salem, OR and still have my parents, siblings and my husband’s family and many friends in Portland, Salem and Eugene. We visit Oregon often.
The location of the proposed destination resorts on the Basin’s perimeter would in my opinion, do severe damage to the delicate Metolius environment. We need to be forward thinking and protect the Metolius from damaging human encroachment.
Please do everything possible to pass SB 30.
Sincerely,
Eva Dougherty
Seattle, WA
I am writing this e-mail to express my support for SB 30 as written. I currently reside in Seattle, WA. However, I grew up in Salem, OR and still have my parents, siblings and my husband’s family and many friends in Portland, Salem and Eugene. We visit Oregon often.
The location of the proposed destination resorts on the Basin’s perimeter would in my opinion, do severe damage to the delicate Metolius environment. We need to be forward thinking and protect the Metolius from damaging human encroachment.
Please do everything possible to pass SB 30.
Sincerely,
Eva Dougherty
Seattle, WA
